Fine Fare Supermarkets Opened: December 2024 Owner: Bejad Musleh Previous Tenants: none Cooperative: Retail Grocers Group Location: 1689 Richmond Rd, Staten Island, NY Photographed: April 14, 2025 Two small new supermarkets opened on Staten Island last December -- a CTown on Castleton Avenue on the north shore, occupying a building previously housing a sign shop, and a Fine Fare in Dongan Hills in a new-build building. This Fine Fare development, which includes the 9000 square foot supermarket and a Starbucks across the parking lot, started as far back as 2017. The structure was constructed by 2021, but it wasn't fully finished and outfitted as a supermarket until late 2024. As you can see in a street view , the property backs up to a hillside, with a retaining wall running behind the supermarket (and limiting its size). The parking lot is on the side, but the store is oriented to face the street. Produce lines the first aisle on the left side of the stor...