The Fresh Market Opened: 2013 Previous Tenants: A&P (1960s-2012) Location: 75 Washington Valley Rd, Pluckemin, Bedminster, NJ Photographed: November 2020 It's time for our first store tour of a Fresh Market! We previously saw a quick look at one up in Westport , CT, and the ALDI in Livingston used to be one as well. Livingston and Bedminster (here, which is also sometimes called Pluckemin, the name of the unincorporated neighborhood here) opened at the same time, but while Livingston was poorly executed in an area with high competition, Bedminster has done quite well with only a Kings nearby (tour the store here ), an affluent market, and execution that's clearly been refined over the years. The 20,000 square foot space was an A&P until 2013 when they lost their lease. Today, The Fresh Market has basically no remnants of the A&P around, not even the facade which looks like it could be built around the centennial facade of the former A&P but is ...