The Market Report

Pathmark Daily Opened: August 2026 Owner: Christopher Sanchez Previous Tenants:  Key Food (2011-ca. 2016) > Shop Fair (ca. 2017-2026) Cooperative: Allegiance Retail Location: 340 Pennsylvania Ave, Brooklyn, NY Photographed: September 4, 2026 It's Pathmark time -- again! When Pathmark went out of business in 2015, the brand was acquired by Allegiance Retail (the cooperative behind Foodtown), with the relaunch starting in 2019 at a Brooklyn location . Earlier this year, Allegiance debuted a second Pathmark -- a small-format one under the Pathmark Daily brand on Long Island. Now, a third one has entered the picture, this one also a Pathmark Daily in East New York, Brooklyn. This one has opened with virtually no fanfare, and that may be because it's still in transition. Let's back up a bit here to review this store's history. It was built from the ground up in 2011 as a Key Food of just under 18,000 square feet. For reasons I'm not quite sure of, Key Food only ...

SuperFresh Opened: October 2023 Owner: Howard Lee Previous Tenants:  ShopRite (1968-1984) > Pathmark (1984-2015) > Price Saver Fresh Marketplace (April 2019-September 2019) Cooperative: Key Food Stores Location: 242 Lincoln Blvd, Middlesex, NJ Photographed: August 5, 2026 Welcome back to the Middlesex SuperFresh! This store opened in the fall of 2023 , and around three years after its original grand opening, it's getting some work done as the store is cut back. It seems like this store never quite got to the volume it needed, though it was decent enough to keep the lights on and the doors open apparently, but it's being cut back from its original size of around 56,000 square feet to around 40,000 square feet -- still a large supermarket, but smaller than originally intended. The owners of the supermarket will open a laundromat in the remaining space along with shifting their UPS store into that area, similar to the change at the Linden SuperFresh (though that seems ...